Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The party that plans the economy.



Why would a political organization plan the economy, as opposed to a specialized government agency? You're confusing dictatorships and planned economies.


Perhaps read “party” as “entity” or “organization of people” as in the phrase “a party to the agreement” or whatever?

That being said, I see no way that a governmental organization which plans the economy could fail to be political, by which I mean, closely connected to highly contentious government policy decisions.


Of course it will be, that's just the nature of making decisions. But these decisions have to be made anyway. It's better if they depend on the policies of an elected government than the whims of rich people.


I'm not sure that the decision do have to be made in the same sense that they are made if there is an explicit policy.

But, regardless, a "specialized government agency" which "plans the economy", would I think invariably be a "political organization".


If I put my cynic hat on for a moment, normal government policies often depend on the whims of rich people as we are, unequal access to lobbying is a problem.


They do. But how do you get rich? By having other people work for you. That cannot happen to nearly the same extent in a planned economy.


I don't think we really need stupidly rich people. Is taxation a planned economy?


A million poor people are rich in aggregate.


What are you trying to say?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: