Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They also sanctioned involved individuals. It's more like a family kidnaps their own kid while he was at your birthday party, and as response you get a restraining order and freeze some of their bank accounts.



The citizenship of the victim doesn't really matter.

You're are not the property of the country where you are a citizen. Especially, not if you live abroad.


Are you saying a kid is the property of his family...?

Anyway, citizenship matters, it is one of the many elements that determine jurisdiction. The US taxes and prosecutes (!) his citizens anywhere in the world, for example; and extradition is a thing.

Legal protection to a foreign citizen abroad is extended by the host country, and that's really what the problem is here: the journalist was effectively protected by European law at all times (going from EU country to EU country with a EU airline), but Belarus invaded our legal space with a competing jurisdiction claim and enforced it with guns and subterfuge. That cannot be allowed.


> Are you saying a kid is the property of his family...?

Hehe, I'll admit that's not a good argument.

> but Belarus invaded our legal space with a competing jurisdiction claim...

They violated an international convention on to which they had signed. In turn it seems reasonable that we no longer extend any benefits pertaining to said convention.

Which is sort of exactly what we're doing.


> Are you saying a kid is the property of his family...?

As far as kidnapping or any other kind of forced movement goes, yes basically.


I think you'll find quite a few legal systems currently disagree with that perspective. I'll give you that it's often the traditional perspective, but the children's wellbeing is increasingly the leading priority of related legislation in developed countries, including on issues like forced movement.


That only matters if there is a conflict, and forced movement rarely causes harm.


Sanctioning individuals annoys the individuals but it rarely has any meaningful political effect.

It's kind of a sign of weakness.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: