Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Exactly this! It’s the whole point of the United States.

If you don’t like the policies of a state enough, you can move to another one! It’s extremely rare that someone can move between regions with different laws if they don’t like the laws of their state. You get to choose your government by changing where you live, if you think one of the governments is wrong or bad somehow.

Sure, there are consequences. And inefficiencies. But if you’re French, you can’t just decide to live somewhere with different laws. It’s challenging to move to another country. Even though the EU has laws that make it easier to move and work in other countries, it’s nowhere near as easy as the USA. Forget it entirely if you live in a less progressive or allied country.

This forces the states of the USA to stay appealing - they compete with each other for population. This works because the Union of states allows people to leave if one becomes oppressive, else that state goes to war with the entire rest of the Union. So the states are forced to be accountable to each other and their people.

Each state is supposed to be independent for this reason, and it’s why I’m a big fan of limiting Federal government power and instead pushing changes at a state level




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: