Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Quick note, confusingly throughout this thread people have used the phrase "wave energy" as essentially a synonym for "tidal energy", they are separate technologies sometimes talked about under the combined category of ocean energy or marine hydrokinetics.

Increased power density is indeed one allure of wave energy vs wind. In the same way that wind is concentrated solar energy, studying the mechanisms and origins of waves show they are essentially a form of concentrated wind energy. So if the difficult design challenges are solved, there is potential for greater energy per unit of structural material which some believe could be associated with competitive cost of energy.

Other allures of wave energy include that it is fairly consistent, with some seasonal variations, and its decoupled from solar or wind which decreases the chance that all renewables resources aren't producing at the same time. Of course this is talking about wave energy where oscillations occur with a period of approximately 4-18 seconds rather than tidal with several periods per day, and for these periods of time flow is essentially unidirectional. Tidal energy, like the link in this thread, often uses underwater turbine but wave energy devices rarely use this design.




Thanks for clarifying! So are the true wave energy designs the variants that use vertical oscillations rather than propeller designs?


Wave energy would be any type of machine that uses the motion of individual waves or swells, rather than tides.

There is a wide range of ideas, most are at small scale, early stage, and no winner has emerged the same way that wind energy has seen the 3 bladed turbine win out.

Wave energy devices exist using almost any type of power take off mechanism - direct drive electric generators, linear generators, compressed air, and hydraulic actuators. Some may even use propellers in water but that's not as common since direction is always changing.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: