Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Probably because they feel that the tide is turning against 3rd-party cookies and maybe even fear legislative action in some markets.

The beauty is that Googles business works just fine with FLOC and their competitors don't.

When third party trackers "abuse" the ids one "obvious" solution could be to only allow "trusted" advertisers to receive it.

If, in a great stroke of fortune, the requirements to become trusted are basically "be Google" I wouldn't be surprised.




The worst part is actually, it will never look like "just be Google", because that would be too obviously evil and be subject to decisive legislative action.

Google's Widevine (streaming media DRM) is a great correlate to this. If you wanted to try and create a great, novel 4th web engine/browser; good luck. Many of the major streaming sites use Widevine. You can't build a browser to stream that content without asking for access to Widevine encryption. Google will not give it to you; they may, eventually, if you build up enough of a userbase, but what browser would be able to build up that userbase without access to streaming media?

Its less about building a bulwark around Google's technology, a clear monopoly, and moreso a bulwark around the Boys Club of Established Big Tech. Then Google can go to Congress and say "we have competition, look, Facebook serves ads".


Also we have to ask the question: does DRM like Widevine even work? One could just take a video recording of their Netflix stream using OBS or something similar, and Widevine can't even do anything to counter it.


> does DRM like Widevine even work?

Yes, you just don't understand what working is. Everyone realizes you can do screen recording, HDMI recording, or just invite a friend over to watch on your screen. What it does do is make the content owners comfortable enough that there is a reasonable level of protection as to allow their content to be streamed online.



Basic software level Widevine will generally not allow you to play high quality content (like probably 1080 or better): https://support.google.com/widevine/answer/6072714?hl=en




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: