Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> But read up further, and make educated decisions. Don't just listen to "experts" blindly.

I don't see that being very practical. The average person simply isn't qualified to read scientific literature and draw their own conclusions. I doubt I'd be able to make much sense of a research paper on virology or epidemiology, despite that I consider myself scientifically literate in the general sense.

The answer is to have credible communicators of science. The best way to do that is with credible institutions. If the assumption is that this is impossible, the game is already lost.

> the Surgeon General and even Fauci, told people that masks don't work. That infuriated me and they instantly lost credibility with me. And it caused a split in Americans where too many believed that masks didn't work, even after they changed their tune. It was absolutely unnecessary to lie and it killed people.

Broadly agree, although I think anti-mask sentiments are due to mindless partisanship rather than listening to Fauci's early lie.




> The average person simply isn't qualified to read scientific literature and draw their own conclusions.

Reading the scientific literature is still "trusting the science".

Are we replicating experiments to see for ourselves if the data is correct? Are we re-working the error calculations to make sure the statistical evaluation is correct? Are we studying the topic so we're informed enough to identify poor work as well as the peer reviewers?

I believe the answer to these questions is "no".


A few centuries back the average person couldn't read at all, so I think there's hope that it can be taught, not just explained.

On the other hand, the separate disciplines are more and more specialized and complex, so then I agree 100% that communication (translation) is key.

Lastly, "mindless partisanship" may be the cause, but is also an effect of other longer/subtler trends in media-tech, culture, education, etc.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: