Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> One only needs to look at California to see that even the most insane gun control has no affect except to limit a constitutional right to those who can afford lawyers and insane requirements.

Except those laws are there on the books next to states with laws that are basically non-existent for gun control. so it's trivial to go there and get a non-complying gun.

regardless of your stance on guns that's not a good argument.




> it's trivial to go there and get a non-complying gun.

Completely false. It’s illegal for an out of state dealer to sell you a gun (or for any dealer to sell you a gun without a background check), and it’s illegal for you to bring a gun back into California unless you lived outside the state, or it was a gift from a parent or child.

If you are willing to buy guns illegally, you can do so more easily within California than by going out of state to do so.


With some exceptions not relevant here (e.g. people holding Federal Firearms Licenses), it is unlawful to buy a handgun in a state where one is not a resident. No gun store will sell or transfer a handgun to a non-resident. And if the state in question allows face to face private transactions, federal law requires the seller determine if the buyer is a resident of the state.


The last part isn't accurate. There is no law that requires this from non-licensees.

As a practical matter, I won't sell to someone I can't verify is a legal resident of my state and has a CCW permit, that way I know they're not a prohibited person -- but there's no law that requires me to do so.


Your correction is incorrect for at least some states. Texas requires a good faith belief (but not evidence per se) that the transferee is a legal resident of Texas (and they recommend but don't require asking for some kind of ID).

https://faq.sll.texas.gov/questions/44008


It sounds like you said what I said... Except that the discussion was specifically about federal law, there are various states that have additional laws.


>it's trivial to go there and get a non-complying gun.

Is it? I haven't tried buying a gun in another state because that's illegal, but I'm assuming it would take some effort.

And honestly, what's the point? For the most part, the things that California bans aren't guns themselves. The bans are focused on how you put the pieces together, as well as what plastic doodads you attach to the gun. It would take about 3 minutes and a screwdriver to turn my two California-legal rifles into two felonies. No need to drive to Arizona and find a gun seller who is willing to break the law by selling to someone from out of state.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: