Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What do you do about unambitious people who live beyond their UBI means and end up being unable to pay the rent?



It's funny how these sort of questions are always being used to counter a safety net for the poor, but at the same time nobody does anything about rampant tax evasion and avoidance, which is much much more money.


It's an implementation question. It's one of the reasons we give people services instead of cash.


What do you do -now- about the ambitious people who live beyond their salaried means and end up being unable to pay the rent?


So what problem does UBI solve, then?


It guarantees a certain level of means. Obviously. It's not intending to address people who live outside their means; there are other controls for that. It's to ensure that a person's means is sufficient to cover their basic needs.

A person who is responsible with $10 a month may not be a credit risk, but clearly can't cover their needs; a person spending $10k a month when their job pays them only $8k is clearly a credit risk, living outside their means, despite earning enough to cover far more than their basic needs. You're strawmanning.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: