Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't understand how it's 'failed' - it is an iconic building. I wish I was able to afford to live there.



That's exactly how it has failed. One purpose was to illustrate that you could build affordable and liveable urban apartment buildings in high number and high quality.

You reporting 50 years later that you wish you could live there (I would also love to), illustrates that this didn't happen.


We can say the same about nearby 'vanilla' condo buildings https://goo.gl/maps/7qm79E799kUKUCPFA Old port is just prohibitively expensive in general.


I think the point is there'd be places like this in more affordable non-sought-after locations, had the vision been a success.


The area is just expensive as hell, final. Some of these cubes are horribly dated, but just the fact it's in the Old Port makes the price shoot way up.


Thats more to do with zoning and permitting.


I mean, you can say that, but, it's all mixed-use highrises around there. There are new thirty-story buildings going up all the time. I don't think there's much more that could be done policy-wise, it's just a desirable area -- and there's condos half the price ten minutes away by metro.


It's a quote (hence the ''). If you read the article you'll see it comes from https://thewalrus.ca/for-everyone-a-garden/, which (as others have said) says it 'failed' to be housing for everyone.


Had they built more of the,, it may have taken off. It had demonstrated the possibilities. Maybe it was ahead of its time.

The choice that other people make does not make the idea worthless or a failure.


It's a failed dream. We don't see more building designed like that in Montreal, just more skyscraper so we can be more like Toronto or New York.


Not a bad thing, Montreal is literally an island and there are plenty of places with ugly moldy and unsafe *plexes wish were demolished and rebuilt like this https://goo.gl/maps/unYizR5WCsLT3QhK7 for example, if you remember how it looked before.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: