Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I was born late 1980s and I think by that point we still didn't have any evidence of extrasolar planets...

...but damn if it wasn't bloody obvious there must be some.




Believe it or not people used to argue that planetary formation can be super rare or even a set of conditions unique to our system. Not quite unlike the current narratives about extraterrestrial life.


I remember my teachers mocking me when I was saying that if the Sun is a star it's rather logical there are planets around other stars and that the view that they don't exist is the extreme one, but I was scoffed at that this is "pure speculation" and "science fiction".

On the other hand, when seeing a model of atom and solar system for the first time I was convinced reality is a set of layers with the micro- and macrocosm being just the two closest ones we're able to perceive, but I'm far less sure of it now.


> On the other hand, when seeing a model of atom and solar system for the first time I was convinced reality is a set of layers with the micro- and macrocosm being just the two closest ones we're able to perceive, but I'm far less sure of it now.

Yeah, I thought like this too until we started covering the basics of quantum physics and our teacher explained to us how the Bohr model of an atom was only a crude approximation of what's happening. I no longer see atoms as miniature solar systems, but every now and then, I ponder if the planets aren't macroscopic electron clouds...


the wikipedia on atomic orbital has some nice pictures of the wave function of electrons around the nucleus. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_orbital


Oh, they certainly are, as scientifically documented in "He Who Shrank", by Henry Hasse.


God bless that planets do not jump to an outer orbit when they get excited :-)


Perhaps we are destined to perceive it like layers because of our perception, and not reality itself :)


The first time we discovered an exoplanet was in the late 90s orbiting I believe a binary pulsar system.


I'd assume people had some some indirect evidence before. I remember some noise about exoplanets during my teenage years - there was a Polish astronomer[0] involved in the first discovery. But I thought to myself, surely everyone expected this to happen? I was later surprised to discover that even in the 90s, people seriously believed there were no extrasolar planets.

(Perhaps theirs was the more scientific position, and I was just a nerd biased by science fiction stories. But then, I was taught the Sun was just another star, and if God wanted our solar system to be special, surely He wouldn't need to create more planets than just the Earth? I guess I had some intuition for Occam's razor before I knew it by name...)

I only got a more complete picture of the timeline of discoveries much later in life, from this video[1].

(EDIT: it seems that the first discovery was in 1992, when I was single-digit years old, so the noise I remember about Wolszczan must have been about the other discovery in 2007.)

--

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleksander_Wolszczan

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gai8dMA19Sw




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: