Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If they are like me, I've never even heard of Geforce prior to your comment ... but am very aware of Stadia ¯\_(ツ)_/¯



Bingo! What on earth is that


It's bundled with the nvidia shield. I played witcher 3 and it was well within the realms of good enough given I had little other option.

You wouldn't catch me trying to play multiplayer on it though, and obviously playing locally on a high performance machine would be better.

Main difference vs stadia is I had to own the game, though there were some free ones.


This does seem to be the problem. Stadia is basically the worst game streaming service, but they make up for it in marketing budget and googles existing name recognition. Unless I'm missing something - which is why I was asking the question.


Meanwhile I've tried every streaming service outside of Amazon's Luna and by far Stadia has been the best experience.

You can buy games and just play them, 1080p60 on hardware you never have to pay for.

Or pay Pro and get 4K, HDR, 5.1 surround sound. Which actually works great.

Stadia has a ton of hate from the gaming community it seems though, articles came out the first few months bashing it but I've had at worst visual hiccups on a wireless mesh network...


> You can buy games and just play them, 1080p60 on hardware you never have to pay for.

Honestly, this worries me the most. There doesn’t seem to be a way to transfer the licenses out of stadia, which means, even though you “bought the game“, you’re still at googles mercy for your continued enjoyment of the game. What if they decide that the hardware costs are too much for Google, and you now have to pay a monthly fee? What if they decide that stadia is not the success they hoped for and close it down (which Google is not known for doing at all…). Unless there are clear migrations paths away from stadia, I’d stay away from it because Google have shown that they are not afraid to change/EOL any of their products with no regards to their existing customers (just look at their lifetime free photos service, etc)


I agree, for the most part, but this is a separate problem to what the grandparent post was talking about. This is a common problem to most streaming services (except, as noted, GeForce Now) while GP was claiming that Stadia was the worst game streaming service. Honestly, of the ones I've tried, it's the best; games look good, perform well, and control with no noticable latency.

Now, why do I buy games on Stadia if I agree with your point about not owning the game? Well, portability is sometimes nice. I can throw a Chromecast in my bag and play a game anywhere. It's a supplement to how I game, but I don't think it will ever be the primary way.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: