Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What rare material could a monolith be made from that would almost certainly suggest extraterrestrial origin?



Probably something that is so scarce in earth that the monolith alone couldn't have been made by anyone other than a government, a billionare or aliens. Solid gold maybe?


hah. gold is not that rare. even an entry level billionaire could afford a monolith this size


Printer ink then ;-)

On a more serious note, Rhodium fits the bill: super expensive, hard, durable, silvery and corrosion resistant.

Using the 7,700 lbs estimate elsewhere here, and a price of Rhodium I randomly found on the internet of $16,100 per troy oz, the material of this structure, if made from Rhodium, would cost about $1,749,005. Which is actually not bad, for a very rich person. I guess they'd have to build an even larger one. Or make it hollow and fill it with printer ink.


I think you calculated that wrong. I get $1.8B at that price.[0] Though that 7700 lb estimate assumed the sculpture was made of aluminum; rhodium is about 4.5X as dense, so it'd be closer to $8.1B.

[0]: 7700 lb * 14.5833 troy oz/lb * 16100 $/troy oz = 1,807,891,701


Ah, thanks for the correction. I just quickly googled values and multiplied them but thinking about it, I probably multiplied by "lb/troy oz" instead of "lb/troy oz" or something like that. I'm an idiot :)

Your figure does sound a bit more realistic. Still, printer ink...


Kamacite might be one of the classics:

"Kamacite is an alloy of iron and nickel, which is found on Earth only in meteorites."[0]

As a bonus, it's shiny grey, which means it could even be what this monolith is made of.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamacite




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: