Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

People living in Japan are used proper train boarding and exiting - they stand on the correct entry markers and the train doors will be on these markers once it stops. In the same manner no one blocks the exit markers and people stand in the queue behind the train door ready to disembark quickly.

Only this makes the 90 second Shinkansen stops possible as well as the 3 minute cadence between trains we saw in Hiroshima station possible. Not only is the platform used very efficiently, there is even a small Soba restaurant in the middle of the platform! :)

In comparison here in Europe (CZ) the trains are usually late and you migh only lern the platform couple minutes before the train arrives - and it might even change at the last minute! There are no door markers and trains stop preatty much at random somewhere at the platform. Most traincars still have stairs and people are not used to proper queueing, so they form a fan around every door that blocks people from quickly getting eiter in or out.

The trains are also slow (160 km/h max on parts of track and on a good day) and mostly not EMUs, so you have platform space used up by the locomotive. Oh well.




Please don't generalise all of Europe based on circumstances in a single country.

In the three European countries I'm most familiar with, at least some types of train stop in a consistent position, with platform markings and queuing.


I really hope so - one gets very used to it while traveling in Japan becase it's so convenient! And then one misses it a lot when getting back.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: