The killer feature here would be HD voice with no squelch crash on simplex or repeater use. Ham used to be ahead of curve on a lot of communication tech. This would at least bring it more even with the newer stuff out there.
Section 97.113(a)(4) of the Amateur Service rules prohibits the transmission of “effectively encrypted or encoded messages, including messages that cannot be readily decoded over-the-air for true meaning.”
What _exactly_ that means is, of course, up for debate. Some say you can use encryption as long as the key is publicly available and obvious (i.e. my key is "password"). There's been a bunch of stuff happening in the last year around Winlink. Devil's in the details.
The practical difference is you can send any sort of data with packet radio, how are they actually going to prove you've hidden an encrypted message inside that without the key (preferably symmetric)?
There are exceptions that allow for use of encryption to authenticate remote control of satellites and such. But generally speaking, it violates the rules to obscure the content of a message.
It's absolutely illegal, unless it's somehow an emergency that requires it. Don't let anyone say otherwise, there are some crazies who think it's legal.
Yes, as long as the key is available. For instance, we use WPA keys for our HAMnet microwave links, but using a well-known key that's publicly known.
D-Star and PACTOR are proprietary, undocumented algorithms but you're allowed to use them because devices implementing them are commercially available.
Our links are essentially standard 5 GHz wifi, but on licensed bands with higher tx power, and we don't want random people to connect to them. A WPA key mitigates that without breaking any regulations.
Mainly a mitigation against curious people with Ubiquiti equipment, which makes it way too easy to disable country restrictions and find and connect to our links in licensed bands :-)
You can easily find it on a public website if you know what you're looking for. It's only meant to deter people who click the "Scan" button on their equipment.
Well depending on what is broadcast, it might have a regular structure and perhaps there's some reason you'd want to randomize the broadcast signal. Maybe some highly specific noise in the environment that happens to resonate with the signal structure?
Alternatively there might be protocols which have mandatory encryption as part of their specification. Or you might be using a combined encryption-authentication mode, but only for the purpose of authentication on ham radio.
Same reason why people use walkie talkies. You get to do voice or data without infrastructure. That's kinda cool.
Also, listening to ATC, satellite telemetry, and other sorts of radio communications can be fun too. It's like having some insight into… a lower level of the world.
You don’t need infra. If the whole world ends tomorrow I can still have a radio based transmission network and a private WLAN composed of HAM radio. Or at least that’s what it is in theory for people.
Its not my thing but I think it’s pretty cool to imagine a large plot of land with several cabins that house relay servers for content. Then you can camp on different locations on your property and listen to music anywhere with the right antenna. Maybe video if you use the right band? There’s a lot of unutilized potential here and in the U.S. you can do a lot with a HAM license.
Hotspots really help with that. Even if there are no repeaters near you a cheap hotspot will let you hop on digital and talk to people all around the world with minimal fuss. People complain that it's not "real" amateur radio, but if you just want to talk it's very accessible.
They never said it was, and it would be fine to have multiple open standards if they are suited for different things. M17 looks to be better suited for digital voice than AX.25.
that is an understatement. AX.25 is a guaranteed-delivery packet-forwarding protocol with indeterminate latency. For audio streaming you need a low, predictable latency and accept drop-out to achieve that.
The killer feature here would be HD voice with no squelch crash on simplex or repeater use. Ham used to be ahead of curve on a lot of communication tech. This would at least bring it more even with the newer stuff out there.