Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>I'm not sure your vitriol is called for here, it seems very easy to selectively enable and disable monetization [1].

Easy for who? And for what purpose?

Implementing an HTML tag that will attempt to charge you money is wrong on so many levels.

If I walk into a store (click on a link), even though I know there's stuff to buy there, the store (website) doesn't have the right to charge me just for walking into the store (hitting the landing page) -- unless they clearly let me know that (perhaps a big sign on the door?) before I enter the store.

And as for what you would or wouldn't do, that's great! You're a stand up guy[0].

Sadly, there are way too many people who would abuse this in a hot minute. Especially since many folks wouldn't even find out about it until they get some sort of transaction notification (with a credit/debit card, that could be weeks).

[0] N.B.: That's not snark or sarcasm. It's good to know that there are still other people who will do the right thing because it's the right thing to do. Thank you.




> Implementing an HTML tag that will attempt to charge you money is wrong on so many levels.

Just a quick clarification. The HTML tag doesn't charge you anything. It just indicates that the website participates in WM and provides a location on where the website can accept a payment.

You still need to subscribe to a Web Monetization provider that actually makes the payment and calculates the amount.

You have 100% control over whether you want to participate in Web Monetization or not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: