Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> he has become too much of a cult figure

I didn't know who PG was until recently. I knew he was well respected on HN but I've never found that much value in his blog posts either. Maybe people like his writings in the light of his achievements, rather than for their intrinsic values.




There are many classic books and movies that people read now and say, what's the big deal? I've consumed tons of material that said this just as well if not better!

What they, and you, fail to realize, is that after the copycats have come in, the pioneer looks outdated. But they are the ones standing on his shoulders, even if, with the benefit of hindsight, they've found more effective ways to spread the same message.


His essays were what attracted people to YC (and HN) in the first place.


This is true, I bought the "Hackers and Painters" book before discovering HN. Pretty inspiring at the time.

This sort of interesting writing seems to have stopped in general. Spolsky and Yegge are other positive examples from that era, which of course is just 10 years ago.


That’s exactly it. Everybody would dream to have his life and his blogs do give a vivid imagery that makes you feel good and believe you can do the same (plus with YC actually giving some hope).

But I’ve learnt a lot more from others, who are not nearly as successful.


Who are some of the other people you've learned a great deal from? I'm curious!


I'm not parent but - it might be people that are close to them IRL and not well known online. Personally, it was like that for me. However unlike parent, I also feel like I get a lot of value from reading PG


We used some of his essays in a freshmen writing class in college 7-ish years ago. I had no idea who he was at the time but the essays still made an impression.

This was a liberal-arts school and the professor had no particular technology or business background; I’m still not sure how she came across them.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: