Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Datafun is quite cool! Formulog and Datafun seem similar---both combine logic programming and pure functional programming---but they take wildly different approaches.

Datafun is a foundational re-imagining of what a Datalog could look like: start with a higher-order programming language and give it a first-class notion of least fixed points. A type system for tracking monotonicity lets you roll your own Datalog. It's impressive that you can reconstruct semi-naive evaluation (morally: in each 'round' of evaluation, only apply rules matching new results) in their setting (https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3371090). Datafun is still a ways away from the performance and implementation maturity of existing Datalogs, though.

Formulog's approach is to try to let Datalog be Datalog as much as possible. We end up with restrictions around higher-order functions and other FP features in order to keep things simple on the Datalog side---quite the opposite of Datafun's fancy type system. Our Formulog interpreter does pretty well with internment, parallel execution, and magic sets, but you could easily port our design to existing Datalog compilers and get even bigger speedups. It's not clear how to do that for Datafun... yet.

(I suspect you could port our SMT interface to Datafun without too much of a problem, too.)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: