Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's known fact that pain has evolutionary advantage but I wonder how could degree of pain has different kind of genetic advantage?



Having spent a few years in horrific agony due to poisoning. I suspect it could be along the long the likes of.

Let’s do the opposite of whatever that guy does.

That guy is moaning for months after fisticuffs with a lion. Let’s try a long stick instead.

That guy slept with girls of that tribe. And his parts burn like crazy. Let’s be monogamous.

That guy eats donuts all day, and every step is agony. Maybe veggies aren’t so bad.


This could be achieved by binary way of pain. Feeling pain or Not feeling pain. Degree of pain may not have any effect on the above scenarios. right?


There is stubbing your toe pain. Watching kids, this does not stop repeat behavior.

Then there is pain that is all you can do to not jump off a cliff to end it. This, tends to change personal behavior.

Then there is pain that is slightly less then jump off a cliff. But it goes on for months, non stop, making every moment a horrible experience. This has a huge impact on all those around you. Some pity you, some try and help, some wish you would die already. Most avoid you.

Degree makes a massive difference. Wish it was otherwise.


Perhaps it made them more empathetic? When I visited the Museum of Human Evolution in Burgos, Spain, they took us out to the Atapuerca excavation site and told us they’d found evidence of a Neanderthal with a life-threatening tooth abscess. Apparently he would have been in incredible pain and his tribe(?) mates managed to keep him alive by pre-chewing his food for him. They also found evidence of disabled Neanderthals who were helped/kept alive by the group but I can’t recall the specifics of the disability to remember whether any pain may have been involved.

I would think pro-social behaviors like that have a serious evolutionary advantage.


What you are talking about is how long the pain exists. Not the degree of pain. Isn't it?


Some people are born without the ability to feel pain. You don't want to be them:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congenital_insensitivity_to_pa...

> Because feeling physical pain is vital for survival, CIP is an extremely dangerous condition.[1] It is common for people with the condition to die in childhood due to injuries or illnesses going unnoticed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: