Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You're arguing against a straw man. The original poster was clear enough: negotiate the contract, if the company won't budge then don't sign. That is your leverage.

There is a question about whether or not the contract is ethical, but that's irrelevant to the original point. Which is simply this: contracts should be negotiable. If they're not, use your leverage.

ALL contracts are negotiable, it's just a matter of which parts. Your salary is part of the contract, and everyone should be negotiating that.




Exactly this was what ended my career with Amazon. I was asked after being there five years to sign a non compete with no consideration.


> You're arguing against a straw man. The original poster was clear enough: negotiate the contract, if the company won't budge then don't sign.

Where did I say that you're not entitled to refuse to deal with companies that won't negotiate with you? Of course you're free to walk away if you the company doesn't want to negotiate with you, but the company isn't doing anything wrong by not wanting to negotiate and there is no legal or moral requirement for them to negotiate.

> contracts should be negotiable

Disagree. Contracts can be whatever the entity who draws them up wants them to be. If you don't like it don't sign it.


Non-negotiable contacts are totally fine and legal. They are called adhesion contracts. Not everything that is enforceable in a negotiated contact is enforceable in a contract of adhesion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: