Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The whole paper passport thing is just ridiculous in the age of ubiquitous digital communications and photography. Any official requiring your picture could take it and send it to an AI for identification right on the spot.



Easy in a "stable" situation like an airport with all the material.

Harder in anything less than a perfect environment. Now what about between non-friendly countries. In a warzone. On a road checkpoint. For the random checks at the gate of the plane or in the middle of the boarding process (for flights to the US they check it both at the gate and on the "boarding platform" now). At least the paper things provides "something" when that's all you have to ID someone.


And what would be gained by that except spending a lot of money, needing to train existing officers and being reliant on a working internet connection?


> train

In most cases this would amount to simply pressing a key and reading data off the screen.


There's currently no national database storing pictures of all German citizen, and I for one would oppose its creation.


Why would you oppose the database of all citizens to also having pictures in it?


It's a step on the road to mass surveillance.


There is also no single database of all German citizens. Privacy is very important in Germany.


There is since 2007, at the Bundeszentralamt für Steuern.

In addition, many decentral databases (such as local registration databases) can be comprehensively and automatically queried by many individual authorities.


There is. Its just not official.


Source?


Judging by the links throughout this thread and the posted article, that isn’t foolproof either.


I agree, and having a barcode on the back of the neck would serve the purpose better.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: