Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Do people have the right to self defense?

Of course, but that's a last resort. You cannot ask someone who is in risk of imminent harm not to defend him/herself, although that should be the minimum use of force needed to fend off the danger (in the US as usual the law is less strict, in Europe you can shoot to defend your life but if it's proven that in that exact moment your life wasn't in danger you'll be charged).

> Please tell me the last time America won a war against a militia or insurrection embedded in the civilian population.

A clear case must be in 1865, when the Union won the civil war- at the cost of between 600k and 1 million dead. But there's of endless instances of the US police or national guard using force to repress protests, uprising and terrorism- as it is normal. It's hard to say whether these movements could have been more widespread if they hadn't been repressed through intelligence and use of force.

But can you point out an example of when a militia or an insurrection won against the US police or national guard?




>But can you point out an example of when a militia or an insurrection won against the US police or national guard?

Afghanistan, 2016.


Haha




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: