Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> It's ridiculous that it takes six or seven officers so long to neutralize the threat, which may not even have been a real threat.

So just kill people to save a handful of officers having to spend 15 minutes sorting a situation out?

> So, you get called to a minor domestic disturbance, the unarmed cops show up and it turns out that the guy in question "upgraded" to a kitchen knife. They'll better be good at keeping him occupied with trivia questions until the properly equipped force shows up.

How do you think it works in practice in the UK at the moment? If someone attacks you with a kitchen knife you can defend yourself and arrest them using a baton or a Tazer - you don't need a gun that's an insane murderous overreaction.

Our rate of both people killed by the police, and people killed by other people, is very low. Learn from what we're doing.




> So just kill people to save a handful of officers having to spend 15 minutes sorting a situation out?

That's a false dichotomy. What if it had been only two officers? That would be the situation if there happened to be a patrol around.

How do you know how the crazy guy would've reacted when facing a gun? Perhaps he would have surrendered.

What about the officer's safety? Having a gun doesn't mean you have to shoot it, it means you have better means to defend yourself and others.

The fact that almost all other police forces in Europe have guns but then tend to not fire them at people tells me that guns are not the problem.

Either way, I'm not willing to put the lives of police officers on the line just to save a couple of machete-wielding crazy people from a "suicide by cop" situation.

> How do you think it works in practice in the UK at the moment? If someone attacks you with a kitchen knife you can defend yourself and arrest them using a baton or a Tazer - you don't need a gun that's an insane murderous overreaction.

No it isn't. If you are getting attacked with a knife, you and or other person, officer or not, are morally and legally entitled to defend yourself and others with lethal force.

For your own safety, don't bring a baton to a knife fight. You can not intervene at a distance and you're risking your life.

As for Tazers, they don't have the same psychological impact as a gun and they have limited range. You're welcome to use them, but I wouldn't put my or any officer's body on the line just to prevent the attacker from harm.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: