Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I said this in another comment, but similarly to this, check out Redux Toolkit (https://redux-toolkit.js.org), the `slices` feature changed my view on Redux entirely. Basically you can have a per-feature slice of functionality rather than having actions, reducers, and constants spread around your code. It's analogous to what hooks did, encapsulating similar functionality.



RTK is great! The only thing I wish was a bit different is the `createAsyncThunk` function. It feels dirty providing the action-type string manually, when for all the other actions, this is essentially invisible.


The idea of having some kind of special syntax in `createSlice` to support declaring thunks has definitely been suggested, and there's other libraries out there that do similar things. But, anything we add to our API has to be supported indefinitely. Because of that, I wanted to release `createAsyncThunk` and `createEntityAdapter` as "standalone" utilities first and see how they actually get used by the community.

I'm definitely open to potentially integrating them together down the road, but I'd rather take it one step at a time and make sure that we're really solving the right problems the right way.

If you do have any further feedback on RTK, please feel free to file issues for discussion!


This is similar to how I've always implemented Redux before using some of my own utilities, but it's nice they have an "official" way to do it now. Does it work well with TypeScript?


Yep, RTK is specifically written in TypeScript, and I have a co-maintainer (Lenz Weber) who has done an amazing job working on the TS typedefs to make sure it works well.

See the "Usage with TypeScript" docs page:

https://redux-toolkit.js.org/usage/usage-with-typescript


That's great!


It does indeed. If you check out the advanced tutorial on the site you'll see it's in TypeScript.


Great, glad to hear RTK is working well for you!


It gets messy once you want to do anything advanced. And even when slices depend on each other (circular dependencies will arise).


Can you clarify what you mean by "messy" and "advanced"?

Circular dependencies are indeed a potential issue, but most people are unlikely to run into that, and we talk about ways to handle that in the docs:

https://redux-toolkit.js.org/usage/usage-guide#exporting-and...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: