Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I wish I could say I disagree, but to be perfectly honest, I was fully expecting a recession last year. As someone may have already mentioned though, between FED basically keeping the market afloat, stimulus working its way through the economy and dollar still riding as a safe haven, it is not that surprising that US economy did not crash, while a good chunk of population is at home and out of commission.

The thing that worries me is that by attempting to prolong it as long as we are, we are basically setting up a stage for a greater depression. We already saw 'sell everything' panic in March.




> The thing that worries me is that by attempting to prolong it as long as we are, we are basically setting up a stage for a greater depression

Killing thousands of people in the name of the economy would also set the stage for an even longer, deeper recession...


If Thanos snapped his finger and disappeared the oldest 10% of the population, ~33 million people, I'd wager that would do far less economic damage than keeping everyone on lockdown for 365 days. The rate of the economy shrinking is going to get worse and worse as more companies go out of business.


I wish we could not communicate in bumper stickers. I did not argue this in any way, but you jumped to a conclusion and I am not certain what that conclusion is based on.


A reply is not necessarily a disagreement or correction. They might just be adding their own opinion and thoughts on to yours.


>it is not that surprising that US economy did not crash

S&P500 crashed 30% in Feb/Mar.


I do not want to make trite comments about how US economy is not the same as S&P500, but I will point that those losses were largely gained back for now. The US economy is still going ( and that is despite lockdown ). Hell, government could declare no business is essential and it would still go on in the form of black market.


> The thing that worries me is that attempting to prolong it as long as we are, we are basically setting up a stage for a greater depression

Why?


Because keeping it afloat indefinitely creates a fake value that does not correspond to real situation on the ground. That reality will eventually burst the bubble and because the bubble appears to encompass just about every asset class, it will hurt everyone.


Revolutions happen when the gap between public pretension and private reality becomes too large.

The same could be said of stock market crashes.


Not really. They happen when whoever holds power gets weak and there is discontent simultaneously. As long as you are strong, the gap can be arbitrary large.


Many dictators have been deposed not because they were weak, but because their subjects grew tired of lies and life under their rule.

Gadaffi, Sisi, Ceaușescu, Romanovs were not weak by any objective measure, they were happy to suppress dissent and kill their subjects and still had a functioning security apparatus when deposed, ordinary citizens just refused to cooperate. If almost the entire civilian population refuses to cooperate, regimes cannot function.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: