Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I sincerely doubt that. It fails the KISS test on a lot of fronts required for scaling. Scaling it up would require kites the size of 747's, the single points of failure (the tether and the hinge) would become exponentially heavier as the strength of the cable would need to increase. By the time those two lines cross you will need unobtanium to stay aloft. It's a neat idea but it is - with present day tech - not deployable at scale with the degree of reliability expected from windpower installations.

Keep in mind that the nacelle of a regular windmill is already quite a complex beast, it has one degree of freedom less and can adopt to gusty winds by simply changing its pitch, there is no need to bring the whole contraption back down to the ground before the wind fails to keep it aloft. The only way you can keep the Makani kite aloft if the wind drops rapidly is by controlled descent and that in turn you can do only about as long as your cables are. Typical generators for 'serious' windmills weigh on the order of 30-100 tons, that's roughly the take off weight of a 737-800 on the high end.

Props for actually building it though, that part - even at the limited scale of the prototypes - is quite an achievement.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: