Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If you have an enterprise, HashiCorp Vault has the best features and integrations that I know of (everyone should be using short lived credentials, but who actually does if they're not using Vault?). If you can't use that, AWS Secrets Manager for its simpler integration of secret rotation, and if that's too expensive, AWS SSM PS. Google Cloud Secrets Manager would be analogous to AWS Secrets Manager.

The benefit of AWS Secrets Manager has been that it integrates directly with other services. In ECS/Fargate, you can create a task definition and list secrets to be injected at run time. It also has features like secret rotation so you don't have to roll your own (well, you kinda do w/Lambda, but they have samples), and you can use things like IAM to lock down access per-secret or per-IAM-ARN-hierarchy.

Like everything in AWS, it'll cost you more, but it'll also eliminate a lot of engineering time. If you're trying to pinch pennies, use Vault or something hokey like pulling a token from AWS SSM PS or S3 and rely on IAM roles/profiles/etc for access control.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: