Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Platform holders (Google for example) also generally refuse to give you information on the submitter, which means you can't chase them down in court even if you want to.



My understanding is Google will tell you that info as well as publish it to the Lumen database. If not, you can always subpoena Google for the exact info in court, it only adds a step.


This is true (in my experience) for search results but not for the chrome web store. Sure, you could take Google to court if you have more money and time to waste...


Searching turns up https://adampash.kinja.com/google-just-dmcaed-my-chrome-exte..., which has the text of an email Google sent out that does include the sender information.

You can submit a counter-notice, and if for some reason they didn't give you the required information I'd expect you could contact support and ask for it.


Yeah, they omitted critical information and rejected my attempts to get the information. They also kept the extension down for a month. I contacted a lawyer about this but the costs would have been extravagant, so.

You'll note how in that example, they provide lots of information on the party that filed the DMCA claim. That info is only provided to you if the DMCA notice actually included the info - Google will for some reason process malformed notices that don't contain the required information, which leaves you with no options.

In this case the person filing the claim provided no information except their name (4 japanese kanji) with no further contact information or other details. I was unable to find them on Google, if that was even their name.


That's a different issue from Google not providing the actual notice.

It shouldn't prevent you from filing a counternotice with whatever information was provided - did it?


It did because literally all I got was a name and a URL. I made multiple requests for the info and got nothing. It seems like they can probably get away with doing this unless you're a big company.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: