Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Segregation doesn't have to be official and in the written law for it to exist.

Segregation is a real fact in every day Israeli life, as I saw in a 2 year stint from '04 to '06. Since we're talking AlJazeera, here's a recent article on segregation and mixed Israeli-Palestinian couples: http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/features/2011/01/201112...




I think it is widely accepted that state-sponsored segregation and institutional racism are wrong, and should be removed.

However, its a lot harder to make the case that it is wrong for people to freely choose to separate themselves into ethnic ghettos in the absence of government controls.

To make a comparison to America, consider an Italian living in a "Little Italy"-style enclave, who believes it would be best for him or her to marry Italian-Americans.

Are they a troubling group? Do we perhaps need UN intervention to ease the tension between them and other near by ethnic enclaves?


>Segregation is a real fact in every day Israeli life

Are you referring to the fact that Jewish and Arab populations live mostly separate towns and cities? This isn't segregation, since this is by choice of what communities people there want to live in. Unless you want to argue semantics and say something like "well technically they are segregated even if it's by choice so therefore it's racist."

Evidence of this communal separation and anecdotes of individuals with prejudice does not amount to systematized racism in Israel.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: