Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Honestly, I think it's more "You know what happens when you piss off the US gov, Youtube?" (Gov shoots TikTok, to make an example) "That's what. Now get back to work."

Youtube has done a lot of stupid things lately that really do feel like it is an external political agenda being forced on them, not an internal one being forced by misguided placation of shareholders.




Could you expand on some of the things youtube has done that you believe might be the result of external political pressure?


YT has been known to remove selfrepair videos or demonization of said videos.


Huh? Since when? This sounds really odd to me because my dad is obsessed with DIY and self-repair videos on YouTube and has never had a problem finding tons of such content to watch daily.


Does that sound like a political pressure thing or just the usual "company complaints / files bs reports and YT complies"?

I'm not at all convinced there is any large scale love for YouTube as far as US policy goes.


I suppose my usage of the word 'political pressure' is nonspecific to US Government entities and more toward the general definition of a general entity's real politik. For example, i would consider a small business owner paying into a protection raquet by a local mafia to be 'caving to political pressure'


It's hard to know what the motivations are.

I really think YouTube like a lot of tech companies will often just take the path of least resistance and say:

"Well that's a lot of DCMA complaints ... just ban'm if our magic script says to, whatever."

It seems like maybe favoritism to another big company, but maybe is just more a reflection of a crappy process and a tech company habit of just letting some magic formula decide and avoiding any extra time / resource consuming process.

Not to say I don't think it doesn't happen as far as some corporate to corporate pressure goes, but it's hard to know.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: