Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Does anybody here use Mahalo? What are some use-cases where it makes sense?

EDIT:

So I checked out the new Mahalo's advertised feature, "How to Convert Fractions":

http://www.mahalo.com/how-to-convert-fractions/

They have a video which is pretty good. (I wonder if creating hi-quality videos scales to satisfy investors?) Then they have the steps in the video in text format with words such as "Fraction" hyperlinked to a spammy Mahalo page:

http://mahalo.com/fraction

Below this content they have "Related" stuff like "How to convert fractions - XXX" where XXX = {Videos, Images, Newsfeed, Twitter}. These are {Google, Bing, Twitter, etc} auto-generated spam/noise and contain no useful information. (You can't auto-generate a sensible feed about converting fractions.)

Overall I'd rate the new mahalo.com as spammy. The videos + transcribed text may be good, but there's too much surrounding crap.




FACT CHECK!!! FACT CHECK!!! FACT CHECK!!!

BTW: The page you are looking at -- http://www.mahalo.com/search/?q=fraction -- is a page we haven't built yet.

When we don't have a page built we show you Google/Bing search results.

These pages are NOT indexed in Google.

So, they can't be google spam. :-)


I didn't say it is FOR GOOGLE. I said that the page contains numerous boxes which are search results from {Google, Bing, Twitter}, which IMO don't add much value to the topic.

For example:

  http://sp.life123.com/bm.pix/fractions2.s600x600.jpg
or:

"@wyrdgirl_aj gurl ima call u after this 930 class... We learnin how to convert fractions to % -_- #bored from @QueenofKings16"

Best of luck with the new mahalo.com.


I was going to ask the same question because the only times I ever hear about Mahalo is from people who complain about how they are spamming. Haven't heard from a single user of the service yet.


The spamming claim on HN is one done by a secret kabbel of SEO's who I've pissed off over the years.

These guys basically obsesses over everything I do and follow me around the social web. They vote my stuff down, flame me and generally try to bust my chops.

They are known as "jayters" because they hate on Jason. I love my jayters, because they make me appreciate how lucky I've been in this life. They have every reason to hate on me: I drive a tesla, I have not one but TWO bulldogs and I get more press they anyone deserves.

Hate on!!


Hi. I've never seen mahalo.com before nor have I commented on it. What I wrote down was my first impression as a user.

Also note that I pointed out the positive: "They have a video which is pretty good." But all the auto-generated stuff surrounding it is noise to me.

Best of luck with mahalo.com.


You're referring, of course, to the Mahalumnati?




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: