Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

All if his suggestions are great until it comes time to pay the bill for them. It's rather naive to suggest that universal child and health care and free college for everyone will make our country so much better without explaining the very serious effects (many of which we probably don't know) that paying for all of it will have.



How about taking 60% of existing military budget and allocating that towards health care?

How about forcing hospitals to buy directly from manufacturers avoiding multi-tier nets of middlemen?

I am not even talking about private medical insurance companies and lawyers...


You're throwing all sorts of wrenches into the gears of capitalism there. Defense spending isn't us taking money and burning it. It's the government buying things from private enterprise (largely American) and employing troops (also American). Same with regulating hospital purchasing procedures, which the market should regulate itself. You can't know what would happen if you stop that cash flow or force it to go somewhere else, but you can be pretty certain it won't be good.

It's clear we can do more to help the poor get health care. Taking money from the rich and our corporations and paying for it is not the easy solution that a lot of people like to daydream about.


Defense spending is the government taking money from everyone and reallocating it, just like any other government spending (and, of course, in many cases, it's a monopsony). You have to consider that a "wrench in the gears" just as much as health care, education or whatever else they spend money on.

One variety of universal health care that has been lauded by economists, even some towards the libertarian end of things, is that utilized in Singapore:

http://www.american.com/archive/2008/may-june-magazine-conte...

Furthermore, to call the current model in the US 'free market' is probably inaccurate, as it's distorted in all kinds of ways, first and foremost because of the strong link between people's jobs and their health coverage.


Defense contracting is the most hideous inefficient case of taxpayer robbery in existence today. I am not saying it is unnecessary, but the politics and waste behind it is astounding.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: