Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Most people are not legal analysts. Your snarky characterization of this overlooks the fact that what can be anticipated at the time consent is given may be overtaken by technological developments, that corporations often structure their activities legally so that 'research' is non-commercial even if it is intended to be used later for commercial activity, and that it's polite to ask before doing something you might hesitate to grant consent for yourself.



People need to be able to say: "oops, undo this permission thing that I clicked OK to, as I now better understand the ramifications of what I clicked ... and I don't like it"


So you should be able to do things like un-GPL code you’ve published?


Do you think people should be able to undo other legal agreements like mortages?


You can cancel a mortgage within the first 14 days in the UK for this specific reason.


There's also a lot of rules to try and make sure the person really understands what it is they are signing up for, with mandated forms etc. And then as you say there's still a cooling off period.


I wonder how everyone would react if Facebook did that with their biggest open source framework.


Facebook is not "people", we can keep companies and individuals to different standards.


Facebook employs lots of lawyers. They are well advised when they make decisions with legal implications.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: