Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'd rather not be classified as insane, thanks.

If you read the OP article, the research suggests religion has positive effects on children. Your response to the corrected findings?




> I'd rather not be classified as insane, thanks.

What would I be classified as if I started worshipping, say, Thanos, and began preaching to everyone about him?

> the research suggests religion has positive effects on children. Your response to the corrected findings?

If it was safe for me to do so, my response would be to go out in my own religious country and film for you all the children throwing stones at animals (which they're encouraged to do so by their elders), all the beggars sleeping next to literal mounds of garbage, shunned by everyone, and the many other problems that religion is supposed to fix.


Given the context, I would classify you as insincere.


What context? Insincere how? I do strongly like a few deities from various fictions. I would gladly eat your ear off about them.


The context is that you clearly believe religion is nonsense, and a destructive force. Therefore if you were to advocate for a religion, you would be either lying or encouraging what you believe to be evil, and therefore evil yourself. Since poverty and ignorance bother you, I think lying would be the more likely explanation.

Liking deities from various fictions is not the same as seeking to open oneself to God.


add: the many other problems that religion is supposed to fix, but it actually produces them or makes them worse.


The negative effects (sexism, homophobia, general bigotry) greatly outweigh any positive effects that might happen. And the things they're generous towards are usually some anti-abortion or anti-LGBT organisations and politicians.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: