Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What do you mean? The source is all open, and the bytecode format is well documented. There's nothing stopping anyone from writing their own with different semantics.

There's no doc on my work as it's private jerk offy personal project that I work on when I get tired of jira tasks and process.

Edit: here's an example of one someone did in rust https://github.com/qmonnet/rbpf




I was saying a eBPF vm running inside the kernel.

A userspace VM that do not have the same capability as the kernel one is not useful when tracing kernel internals.


You can patch your kernel, or write your own vm. BPF is ultimately just a kernel module under Linux. My vm runs in kernel space just fine as well (but is built on something that looks more like sel4 rather than Linux on the inside).

If you provided enough of std, or ported that VM to no_std that rust vm would work just fine in the kernel too.


This is an interesting option.

Although in our case, our eBPF runs in external customer's environment, and we cannot ask them to patch their kernels with our code.


I feel like we're talking on two different levels here.

It's sort of like how Oak was this neat virtual machine for running on a early 90s PDA prototype. Then the writers of that VM realized that they had written a really general purpose VM, cleaned it up and released the first Java.

This general of a VM (talking about eBPF now) hasn't been a first class citizen of a mainstream kernel before. The devs are taking a very cautious approach (as they should), but ultimately eBPF is way bigger than a tracing tool. I wouldn't be surprised to see nearly everything you currently do with a kernel module ultimately being allowed by eBPF too. Maybe more like emulating other OS's kernels as easily as you'd start another container.


Also different time scale.

I am on existing stuff can be readily used. You are probably estimating the future, I guess?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: