Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's been a while since I looked into it (I don't have kids or plan to), so I can't give you references, but I remember coming to the conclusion that there's little difference in outcome between formula and breast milk, once other factors are taken into account.

It's better to feed your child breast milk, if only because it's cheaper and there's no particular reason not to. But there's now an entire culture shaming parents who choose feed their child with formula instead of breast milk, even though there may be (and often are) extenuating circumstances for their choice.




> It's better to feed your child breast milk, if only because it's cheaper and there's no particular reason not to

Downsides: Only mothers can breastfeed = more work for them. Yes you can pump and refrigerate and have dad feed later with a bottle but pumps are garbage, time consuming and makes mom feel like a cow.

Moms may feel self conscious breastfeeding in public and in conservative cultures it's probably impossible.

Mastitis: painful infection. Already had this 2x in 5 months, requires antibiotics.

Our first kid was formula fed, our second breastfed. Second one is much less work for me as a dad.

Main upside to breastfeeding is that you don't need to carry around formula for two years, find a microwave, sterilize bottles etc. When traveling this is gold. Another upside is that I think breasts tend to stay in better shape aesthetically when not breastfeeding.


I don't agree with the shame at all, and my personal opinion is it's probably better because it's cheaper and equipment-free as you say and years of evolution mean that it works well enough in most cases.

While looking into this though I noticed that a manufacturer's site (https://nutricia.com.au/early-life-nutrition/karicare.html) actually has a popup saying that breastfeeding is better. I wonder what prompted that, community outrage?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: