Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm reasonably sure it would be possible to implement appropriate DSP Voodoo Magic (aka finite response filters) on the Teensy that does a _pretty_ good job of all of these things.

However, I agree with the OP that it does have a fairly large number of shortcomings:

-- The number of man-years that have been spent on commercial products is huge, and they provide a highly optimised solution in a competitive domain. My late grandfather had, in the 1970s, a hearing aid with feedback reduction powered by an analogue computer (aka "electronics") that hung around his neck. -- A lot of the tuning parameters of these algorithms really are hardware specific and would require quite a lot of tuning /iteration -- At the end of the day, a Teensy is a moderately large rectangular board that will not fit behind your ear, has nonzero power requirements, and is a general purpose CPU. A 3D printed case is an expensive way of making a plastic box to put it in. If you were going to go down the open hardware route, you'd start somewhere very different, with power efficient dedicated DSP units on a small, thick multilayer board milled to be a bit more ergonomic. A modern hearing aid needs a new battery every month or so, and is powered by a 0,54 g 1.4 V 180 mAh battery (that is a 4x6 mm cylinder [h x d]). You're not going to get anything like that for a general purpose CPU.

Still, this is a fun project, and I commend people doing it. As ever with anything to do with the USA and healthcare products, however, I can't help but think that their efforts would be better spent trying to get universal healthcare. The cost to the NHS for two hearing aids, multiple fitting appointments included, is around £400.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: