Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Holy shit, that quote. Did absolutely not expect that (even though I assumed thorough telemetry is sent to Microsoft itself).

I've been sitting for months on this article explaining my belief that advertising is a cancer on modern society, and I can't get myself to publish it, because literally every other day brings another thing I want to include on the list of damage being done. I'm not even actively looking for examples anymore; I just open HN and - lo and behold - top story tells me that MS Office mobile apps send data to US predictive profiling company, because of course they do.




A thought you could add to your article. In the medieval period in Europe, advertising outside your shop was strictly forbidden because it was considered an assault on your senses. I totally agree with this sentiment.


Interesting. Do you have a source for that? Not that I'm inclined not to believe you, but I'd really love to read more on that. Thanks in advance. =)


Thanks for that thought! Definitely fits in there. Do you have a link to some source about that, though? I'd love to know about this in more detail.


Phillip Campbell (aka Boniface) of http://unamsanctamcatholicam.blogspot.com/ should be able to point you in the right direction, he is a medieval scholar.

Edit: Sorry I don't have any exact citations, he said it in an interview wit Ryan Grant, so I'm sure he has a source he read somewhere.


All good, thanks!


> top story tells me that MS Office mobile apps send data to US predictive profiling company

That by itself isn't necessarily damaging though, is it? Without knowing what company is getting the data, what data they are getting, and what they are profiling for, how can we come to any conclusions?

What if they are just trying to segment users into casual and power users and are using the data to guide future product development and design?

That said, the data sharing should definitely be opt-in.


> What if they are just trying to segment users into casual and power users and are using the data to guide future product development and design?

Is that something you'd hire an external marketing company for predictive profiling, though?

Sure, the quote doesn't give much information about the company and their use of data, but when evaluated in context of typical data sharing with third parties, it's highly damning until proven otherwise.


> Is that something you'd hire an external marketing company for predictive profiling, though?

I don't know. Are there predictive profiling companies that don't work in the marketing sector?


You don't need predictive profiling for product QA.


Cell growth isn't necessarily damaging though, is it?

At least, unless it is cancer cell growth.

Oops.


So any cell growth should be assumed to be cancerous?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: