Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Sounds silly, but feel free to become a corporation. Well, it's not quite as easy as I say. When I went remote I had to start my own contracting company. Because I live in Japan and (at the time) corporations were the default company configuration, my contracting company was formed as a corporation. There are lots of advantages:

- I can deduct the rent for my work space. In fact, theoretically in Japanese law I can even rent an entire building and offer myself the ability to rent living space for about $150 per month, with the company eating the rest as a loss. Probably you can do something similar in other countries (although I couldn't actually do it... because in order to rent a place I need a company and in order to form a company I need an address... so... well, it didn't quite work out).

- Internet, some of my utilities, etc, etc are expenses. Some furniture as well. Some of it has to be depreciated, though, so I don't get the benefit immediately.

- I can set my salary to anything I want. If it is beneficial for the company to make a profit and for me to make peanuts, then it's fine. If the opposite is beneficial, then it's fine.

- A fair number of expenses can be deducted by having a life insurance plan for employees, etc, etc.

On the downside:

- I have to submit all my accounts using dual entry accounting. The government gets stroppy if I make a mistake because they expect me to be a corporation.

- I have to submit year end accounting. Seriously, I have no time for this and employ a wonderful tax accountant to do this for me. My tax accountant saves me money, but getting a good one is like getting a good car mechanic -- it's hit or miss and can be very expensive if you choose the wrong person.

- I have to do the payroll, calculate withholding tax, pay fees and employment taxes. I have to do this every month and if I'm late I get a really big fine. Luckily my wife does this (seriously, I would never do this without my wife doing all the heavy lifting)

- I have stupid amounts of bank fees because I have to transfer money between 3 different banks just to pay myself. We actually use a sneaker net in one phase: I literally withdraw our payroll from the ATM and deposit in another ATM just to save $20 in transfer fees. Of course, I have to document all of this so the government knows I'm not fiddling anything.

In the end, it's an absolute PITA. I don't really recommend it. I think I save a little money this way over when I was being paid salary. It's really hard to tell, though. However, if you factor in all the work that I need to do, I think I'm being paid about $2 an hour for that effort. Or I should say my wife is. If I didn't have her, it would not be worth it at all.




>although I couldn't actually do it... because in order to rent a place I need a company and in order to form a company I need an address... so... well, it didn't quite work out

Couldn’t you get the building first, register as a corporation, then subsidize all following months through the corporation?


Unfortunately no. The corporation has to either buy or rent the building and it is not allowed to rent it from the owner of the company (and rent it back again at a loss -- for obvious reasons ;-) ). I could potentially buy a building, sell it to my company and have the company rent back my living space. But my company doesn't have anywhere near enough money to buy a building outright. Also in Japan, new companies are treated as toxic waste by the banks, so no loan is possible (and probably "I'd like to get a loan to buy a building and rent it back to myself at a loss to the corporation" is not a viable business plan as far as the bank is concerned anyway...). I can't even get a corporate credit card! We do all of our transactions in cash, if you can believe it.

What I could do is rent a building with the corporation now and move the corporation. The problem is that you have to reincorporate the company at the new address (which would cost me about $3K). Japan is the land of bureaucracy after all! (Edit: I will likely do this if we decide to move since I'll have to pay that money anyway).

The tax break is really to accommodate companies that build a new factory and then build housing for the factory (or a house next to the factory for the owner). It's not really intended to be used the way I want to use it (to literally live in the work space).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: