Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Are you opposed to all kinds of intellectual property protections or just this one domain? In particular, why should anyone put R&D into developing better varieties of crops if their innovations aren’t protected? Or perhaps improving crops (to be more drought resistant or to produce higher yields) doesn’t strike you as important—if so, how do you suppose we produce the additional food to sustain our growing population, especially in light of climate change (reduced land, increased droughts and other causes of crop failure). I don’t know about this particular case, but I wouldn’t rush to advocating for zero IP protection for crop varieties.



I'm against all kinds of IP. The government does not have a right to tell you what you can do with your own property.

> In particular, why should anyone put R&D into developing better varieties of crops if their innovations aren’t protected?

Why should people write free software?

> if so, how do you suppose we produce the additional food to sustain our growing population

Population is nearing or below replacement in developed nations. We don't need to produce more food, we need to stop exploiting developing countries so their standards of living increase.


>> I'll say ok to people owning a potato brand, ...

> Are you opposed to all kinds of intellectual property protections or just this one domain?

I tried to make this clear above: I can see some public value from some sorts of IP.

> In particular, why should anyone put R&D into developing better varieties of crops if their innovations aren’t protected?

Same reason farmers and monks have always worked to improve their crops?

Same reason why KDE, Gnome and Linux exist? Making it better for me doesn't necessarily mean I have to make it useless for you?




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: