>How can you say that "the alternative is unbearable"is beyond me, unless you're saying it's better to become mentally disabled than suffer from depression?
Most people who would be considered eligible for ECT are actively suicidal; if they are released from hospital, they are almost certain to attempt suicide. Some are suffering from catatonic depression and are too depressed to perform even the most basic tasks, often including eating and drinking. The overwhelming majority are being held on secure psychiatric wards for their own protection. The alternative to ECT is usually death. If you don't understand this (or refuse to acknowledge it), then you don't understand why doctors continue to use ECT.
Chemotherapy is horrible. It makes you constantly and violently nauseous, it makes your hair fall out, it can cause lasting physical damage and the side-effects are sometimes fatal. It's horrible, but it's better than the alternative, which is dying of cancer.
The evidence is overwhelmingly clear that ECT is a life-saving medical intervention.
The first link you posted is a highly biased summary of evidence compiled by CCHR, a known Scientology front group; Scientology opposes all forms of psychiatry, largely because of the belief that its own (completely unproven) method of Dianetics is capable of resolving all forms of mental distress. Please see DanBC's comment for a more accurate summary of the evidence.
Most people who would be considered eligible for ECT are actively suicidal; if they are released from hospital, they are almost certain to attempt suicide. Some are suffering from catatonic depression and are too depressed to perform even the most basic tasks, often including eating and drinking. The overwhelming majority are being held on secure psychiatric wards for their own protection. The alternative to ECT is usually death. If you don't understand this (or refuse to acknowledge it), then you don't understand why doctors continue to use ECT.
Chemotherapy is horrible. It makes you constantly and violently nauseous, it makes your hair fall out, it can cause lasting physical damage and the side-effects are sometimes fatal. It's horrible, but it's better than the alternative, which is dying of cancer.
The evidence is overwhelmingly clear that ECT is a life-saving medical intervention.
The first link you posted is a highly biased summary of evidence compiled by CCHR, a known Scientology front group; Scientology opposes all forms of psychiatry, largely because of the belief that its own (completely unproven) method of Dianetics is capable of resolving all forms of mental distress. Please see DanBC's comment for a more accurate summary of the evidence.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_Commission_on_Human_R...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_and_psychiatry
Your second link is to a citizens petition orchestrated by a law firm; the petition was rejected by the FDA on the basis of the evidence.
https://www.regulations.gov/contentStreamer?documentId=FDA-2...