Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Replying to sibling: "Percentages certainly can be misleading, but they aren’t always. Your hypothetical is an example of how they can be. Consider a different hypothetical: the price was $13.50 and he raised it to $750. Is it misleading to report that as raising the price 5000%?"

Yes, it is incredibly misleading. How many people are affected? In practice, do the end consumers see this price increase? What caused the price increase? When was the last price increase?

I understand, 5000% is a fact in the story. However, it is sensational and the exact reason why you see it in about half the headlines of the story.




You keep giving hypothetical reasons why it might be misleading if certain things were true. I’m not interested in that. I can think of a million ways it could be misleading.

I want to know how it actually is misleading in this particular case. You were happy to provide specifics before. If you don’t have any now, then it’s wrong to insist that it definitely is misleading.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: