These are mature stocks, which are basically a random walk, unless you have some insider info.
What'd be really interesting would be if you got a couple thousand speculative plays on there, and allowed people to only submit on the industries they knew something about. Although that'd probably just lead to people only submitting their pet stock as "going to the moon!"
1. Every stock is a random walk.
2. Insider info for smaller companies is much more valuable then larger companies.
3. Speculative plays would make this even more boring, because then everyone makes wild guesses at the future value of a company they have never heard of.
Every statement you made was a complete misunderstanding of my statement. Including the sarcasm, I was being genuine in my praise.
Briefly, the random walk factor is less of an issue for speculative stocks because they either make it as a business, or don't. That's not a random walk. And I really don't understand why you're so miffed.
What'd be really interesting would be if you got a couple thousand speculative plays on there, and allowed people to only submit on the industries they knew something about. Although that'd probably just lead to people only submitting their pet stock as "going to the moon!"
Nice job in any case though.