Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Survallience capitalism is a troubling trend and they may share blame for participation but blaming Google for it /existing/ is just disingenuous scapegoating. Long before Google was a thing stores were trying to get addresses and advertisers were trying to manipulate behavior and they have literally nothing to do with industrial outsourcing.

Former intelligence agents have gotten into business intelligence as well engaged in legal surveillance work to predict trends just doing things like counting cars in factory lots from public spaces to analyse worker demand and thus production and sales - surveillance and capitalism are bridged by being in the same reality and a legal system where everything not forbidden is permitted.




> blaming Google for it /existing/ is just disingenuous scapegoating

I never said they created it; Google, FB, etc, are the "leading forces pushing the world" into a new type of economy. It almost certainly wo9uld exist without Google involvement, but the are involved and the damage from their business model is real.

> literally nothing to do with industrial outsourcing.

I don't see how this is in any way related to surveillance capitalism.

> counting cars in factory lots from public spaces to analyse worker demand and thus production

You're talking about specific examples of surveillance, which are only tangentially related to surveillance capitalism. As the article linked above explains, surveillance capitalism is an economic system with a new form of market. Capitalism has had many forms: mercantilism, factory and mass-production capitalism, financialization, etc. Each of these created unique types of market that incentivized different types of business practices.

An example of the problem from the previous [1] that illustrates the kind of economic change that Google/etc are causing:

>> Three or four months ago, the CEO of Ford says there’s a global auto slump, it’s really hard to sell cars, but we’re getting downgraded in the markets. He says, we want price-to-earnings ratios like Google and Facebook. How do we do that? We’re going to become a data company. We got 100 million people driving around in Ford vehicles. And what we’re gonna do is, we’re gonna now figure out how to get all the data out of this driving experience.

The problem isn't minutia like counting cars in a factory lot or a business trying to advertise to their customers; this is about creating an economic system that gives the most profit to whoever creates the most invasive surveillance so they can sell your pattern-of-life.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: