Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I've had this feeling in some place that 'SOA' is a bit of a dirty word because it connotes a certain style of systems architect, or working like you do in Java or enterprise-scale PHP.

Many monolithic apps would benefit from a refactoring towards that rather than distributing a call stack across the network. The microservices can come later on if there's a need for it. If nothing else, it'll present a clearer picture of how things fit together when you start enforcing boundaries.




SOA also brings up memories of soul destroying ESB's.

I would love a resurgence of discussions about services and how to best build and govern those without always resulting in a focus on the micro versions.

How are people building a modern IT landscape consisting of different services and system?


The problem with ESBs in my opinion is one of tight coupling; all of these distributed systems that know about and depend upon each other. The solution to this is to loosen coupling whilst formalising interfaces/contracts/schemas, with a design that enables versioning and mandates graceful evolution. The modern version of ESB is an event based (note: this does not necessarily and probably does not mean event sourced) architecture built upon a distributed, append-only log that is ideally fed directly from a database transaction log.


ESB is new to me but just casting a glance on it makes me think... Kafka.

You can't avoid the centralisation unless you want infinite repetition.

The human spine is composed of multiple vertebrae and forms a consistent network with the brain and CNS and the rest of your body. The spine itself is the centralism, no matter how much you separate the bones into vertebra.

A service bus is basically putting all of your eggs into one wire. Or so it seems... it's so easy to strawman yourself to microservices.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: