Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Metadata + Countries where Rule Of Law doesn't apply + "Law" Enforcement requests

E.g. Middle East countries




Rule of law doesn't imply strong privacy. In fact, I'd argue that privacy and rule of law are fundamentally in tension. Privacy favors scofflaws, particularly those trying to corrupt the law, so in any social system with privacy there's going to be a tendency toward asymmetry of privacy in favor of the corrupt.

The ideal scenario for rule of law is no privacy. However, privacy has intrinsic value of its own so we're stuck trying to maximize privacy while minimizing the corruption. It's an ongoing balancing act; every society will do it differently and it will change over time.


If we can assume Facebook's apps aren't lying (i.e. E2E is properly implemented - this seems to be the case with WhatsApp) then this is better for those exact purposes.

Even the star child Signal [1] has to store metadata...

[1] https://signal.org/


You get what E2E encryption is, right?


You get what metadata is, right?

That FB doesn't get to snoop what you're saying doesn't prevent them from knowing who you are saying it too. They still control the app.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: