Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Facebook is the new cigarettes (medium.com/futuresin)
45 points by MichaelKSpencer on Nov 14, 2018 | hide | past | favorite | 19 comments



Could quit FB (took around 2-3 years and wasn't easy) but now I am super addicted to some Reddit subs such as r/mechanicalkeyboards.

Addiction is higher than with FB but it doesn't make me feel miserable.


I have same problem with hacker news after I quit FB lol


I believe that's what is called a hobby.


I wouldn't class looking at hobby subreddits a hobby. Actually building, replacing keys, fixing or taking photos of keyboards is the hobby part.


Quitting Facebook was 1000X easier than quitting cigarettes for me.


Good insight but way too old.

In the 00's we already knew Facebook was the new cocaine. Us being the 20 somethings that spent all our lives online creating content in the UGC web 2.0 days.

Everyone wanted to try it.

Cool if you had it.

Fun for parties.

But then we got old.

Now funny enough it's passed on to the old old (40, 50+ and the mainstream), and to them it's reality.

It didn't get passed to the younger kids (18 and below), and the young folks (20-27's) are bored with it.


We can look forward to the same tactics cigarette and fossil fuel companies used being repeated, from funded papers being released, to the same law firms etc etc


I am in my own bubble but I rarely see any papers that claims positive things about Facebook. Do you have any exanples ?

edit: woops, I wasn't reading with enough attention and missed the "forward" word (you know what I am going to blame), sorry.


Grandparent said "we can look forward", so that's probably just a prediction.


Maybe contrary to the trend, but I've never hated facebook, it provides a utility for me to stay connected with friends, especially new ones I would have lost track of in my phone contact.

I tried really hard to understand why some people hated it, and at least for some people I know, it seems to stem from the fact that they are trying very hard to impress everyone in their circle / follower, which takes a ton of time and can even be stressful.

It seems there is no way Facebook or other social media can make those people happy, because they are drawn to the attentions they can get, but many eventually grown to hate the work they have to do to maintain it. Only if there is a way to stay popular without constant hard work!


I'm not sure why Facebook is always singled out with these comparisons.

If FB is the new cigarettes (which feels like an absurd comparison), then Twitter and Youtube are just as bad — and they've done even less to counter the negative externalities their engagement algorithms create.

I think Twitter dodges this criticism mostly because of how popular the platform is with journalists.


I wonder what the author thinks about WeChat (which he prominently mentions just below his name).


WeChat has low penetration in the US and also is not HQ’d there; thus, even if you think it ought to be regulated - probably outside the scope of the US government.


and AdBlock is the HEPA filter.


More like the nicotine patch made and sold by big tobacco


This metaphor doesn't make any sense. Adblock is removal without substitution.


Maybe they meant Adblock specifically (vs, say uBlock)

https://medium.com/varanida/is-your-ad-blocker-selling-you-o...


they get a ton of money from Google


Not a good metaphor, since Nicotine itself is not harmful.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: