Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Being fair, the advertisements can be switched off

Sorry, but Citation required.

I've installed more than my fair share of Windows 10 Home and Pro versions, had both shipped on new devices and nowhere was I offered any options which controlled installing this shit.

> a problem that doesn't necessarily exist in the way that people might think

Even if it was a shortcut to the Windows Store, but it still there eating up space on the start screen... But even still it doesn't help.

I have to go uninstall it (because yes, it's actually installed goddamn Candy Crush and other shit for me)

I'll open up my laptop and find it's decided that it'll install Windows Update right now and fuck whatever I wanted to do with the machine.

Worse, once it's completed it's screwing with my machine, it's gone and re-installed shit, and now bugs me (again) about "Hey, instead of using Chrome, how about you use Edge!" and has reset a bunch of other system options to be the way MS wants them.

I'm hardly alone in this experience - I saw at least half a dozen presenters at NDC Oslo last year bitching about this happening to them the morning of/right before presentations, and I've had it happen to me during meetings/conference calls/etc - where it's fucked off with work that I'm in the middle of.

Windows 10 is why I'm on a full-on effort to move my primary machines over to Linux after decades of Windows use.




It’s in the advanced options of the install process..............


Ok, which specific advanced option, and where? Are certain key combinations required? Is it only settable by putting options in a config file?

Please be specific, and/or link to any relevant documentation.

'cause I hit Advanced any time there was an option, and switched every privacy setting/tracking option off. Yet it still installs ads for Office, various other Bing shit, Installs Candy Crush, etc.


During the OOBE, one of the options is 'Tailored Experience'. The blurb under it notes that disabling it will disable ads and recommendations.


I just tried this on a the latest version of Windows 10 and with everything disabled during the OOBE I still get Candy Crush, Twitter, Minecraft, Get Office, etc. in the start menu.

How do I avoid those using settings in the OOBE?


Those I don't think you can get rid of because they're shortcut files that happen to show up in the Start Menu by default. Easily enough gotten rid of, though.


Update your complaints to match the updated situation, please.

Candy crush does get installed on fresh Win10 installs, and the person responsible for that deal was drummed out of Microsoft, I believe, and once that agreement expires, that'll stop. In the meantime it takes literally 5 seconds to right-click the icon and choose "uninstall" then click the confirmation, and it wont ever come back.

Removed applications do not get reinstalled on a patch or OS upgrade.

Turning off advertisements turns off advertisements, and it will never switch back on by itself.


> Update your complaints to match the updated situation, please.

I don't understand what you mean by updated situation? Have things changed in the last month or two? From a commenter above, that's apparently not the case.

> once that agreement expires, that'll stop

Microsoft is large enough and profitable enough that if they actually cared, they'd pay out the agreement's terms and stop it. They could actually use it as a "We're sorry, we've stopped doing this" marketing to the folks who're pissed off about it.

> Removed applications do not get reinstalled on a patch or OS upgrade.

This isn't true, I've uninstalled various Xbox, Bing, Skype, "Get Office" and other stuff a few times now on the one machine.

> it takes literally 5 seconds to right-click the icon and choose "uninstall" then click the confirmation

And to repeat that again for eeevery damn ad/preload application. It takes a damn sight longer than 5 seconds to remove the ones you can actually remove. But there's still other preloaded apps like OneDrive that I can't remove or even hide.


> I don't understand what you mean by updated situation? Have things changed in the last month or two? From a commenter above, that's apparently not the case.

Things have changed since Windows 10 was released, yes. The last 3-4 releases have honored your uninstallations; if you remove candy crush, upgrades to newer versions of Windows 10 will not replace it, UNLESS the image used to upgrade marks it for installation. The stock Windows 10 media from Microsoft does not, so stock media from Microsoft will not reinstall anything you uninstalled before you began the upgrade.

Other commenters agree with me, as well. Something situational to you is putting them back, I suspect.

>> it takes literally 5 seconds to right-click the icon and choose "uninstall" then click the confirmation

> And to repeat that again for eeevery damn ad/preload application. It takes a damn sight longer than 5 seconds to remove the ones you can actually remove. But there's still other preloaded apps like OneDrive that I can't remove or even hide.

It only takes me 5 seconds, but maybe my computer performs better than yours. If you're not on an SSD I can see why you say it takes longer than 5 seconds, certainly. You only need to uninstall the one time before upgrading to one of the last 3-4 releases of Windows. I forget exactly which one implemented the change. If you are using Windows 10 versions prescribed to you by your IT department, then all bets are off, because a lot of things tend to get customized in those scenarios and I can't know about those customizations and/or limitations.

If you use a Microsoft account, your settings for ads and other personalization preferences will persist across all devices you use that account on. You don't even need to associate your login details with your MSA, simply logging into that MSA on the account in question is enough to sync up those things.


Maybe I did it wrong, but I intended to switch it off and I still get ads after updates on my gaming machine.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: