Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Indeed. There were 18th century mathematicians like Gauss who realized the importance of the geometric nature of complex numbers, but it didn't become central to the subject until the 19th century. The appearance of imaginary numbers as formal square roots of negative numbers goes back to the mid 16th century. As for Cartesian coordinates, i^2 = -1 has an intrinsic, coordinate-free interpretation in terms that would be instantly recognizable to the ancient Greeks, but it's certainly true that this way of thinking wasn't at the basis of the discovery and initial development of complex numbers, and thinking of geometric operators as generalized numbers would have seemed pretty alien for most of the 19th century as well.



> and thinking of geometric operators as generalized numbers would have seemed pretty alien for most of the 19th century as well.

Do you know of any resource treating that subject explicitly? I assume you mean the same kind of operator as in 'differential operator'—is that right? I can kinda see it maybe... but would definitely be interested in hearing the idea expanded on :)


By an operator I just mean a transformation. Certainly linear operators like differential operators qualify. The fact that these have an algebra in their own right goes back to work in the 19th century by Felix Klein and Sophus Lie on transformation groups and to later 20th work on linear algebra and functional analysis. It's stuff pretty much everyone learns as an undergrad nowadays, but the fact that you can do algebra on operators hardly without thinking is a relatively modern perspective.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: