Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't think moral and philosophical conclusions are universal in any way. In fact, there's a lot of mismatch between our everyday modern morals and the ancient (or even recent) moral and political religious texts.

I do think there's universality of moral and philosophical questions. King Cyrus and #metoo debated the same questions. Plato/Socrates, René Descartes & The Matrix constructed story worlds to highlight the same epistemological problem (what if the world isn't real).

Good stories give you a richness of scenarios and questions to discuss, whether you agree or dissent to the author's conclusions.




I totally agree. Hence why I didn't say they necessarily provided the answers. Though I think our cultures are often deeply intertwined with their religions, which do provide a framework of answers to many of the questions (whether you actually practice said religion or not).


The Iliad and The Odyssey draw pretty murky moral conclusions.


Moral murkiness is a good thing, imo. Show's conflict. Some of my favourite stories are all about murky waters of morality.

Moral badness.... Realistically, every morality other than one's own is bad and so statistically...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: