Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>> the Japanese certainly don't have a monopoly on questionably consistent relationships with animals.

There are some unique aspects to Japanese whaling. It isn't just about eating whales, nor is is about culture. The scant studies that have come from their "research" whaling operation suggests they see whales as a competitor species for fish (focus on stomach contents etc). The dark interpretation of this is that they don't want whale populations to increase, that they are killing whales for no other reason than to make them dead. That would be a very unique human-animal relationship imho. I cannot think of any other species with which we compete for sustenance.

For perspective, the world sperm whale population probably consumes as much fish as the entire human population harvests from the ocean.




Foxes, locusts, crows, coyotes...


They eat the food we grow or raise, an artificial construct. Not since agriculture have we directly competed with foxes for our dinner.


Whether we raise it or hunt it, it's still our dinner and we are competing for it.


> Not since agriculture have we directly competed with foxes for our dinner.

There are many, many, many, many, many post-agricultural fables of foxes stealing food from humans.

Ever heard the expression "fox in the henhouse"?


Stealing livestock. An artificial situation of our own construction. Not us both out in the woods chasing the same rabbit. Fox is a pest. We do not compete.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: